Shelter Island Cape Code with Deeded Waterfront Access

Rental Registration #2024-L-0099. This Shelter Island Cape Cod, located in Menantic Peninsula on a quiet lane, is freshly renovated and ready for the summer. A rocking chair veranda along the front of the home facing east is an inspiring spot to start the morning. The front foyer opens up to expansive living spaces, with one delightful surprise following another. The formal living room and dining rooms flow easily to an open kitchen with breakfast bar and an adjacent library/tv room with half bath and access to outdoor entertainment deck. There is a spacious first floor en-suite primary bedroom tucked off to the south side of the home. Along the opposite side of the home are three guest bedrooms and a hallway full bath. The second floor has a beautiful en-suite guest bedroom suite with living area. The lower area has a media room and full bath. From the rear entertainment veranda, a veritable outdoor living room with ceiling fans and comfortable furniture, the grounds are dotted with flowering shrubs and are aglow with sunset skies. Just a couple of doors away is an 8-acre preserve with walking trails where migrating birds and long legged waders pause along a natural pond. There is a deeded easement on Menantic Creek where one can bring kayaks or just enjoy the waterfront scenery. New to the rental market in 2025, this pristine Shelter Island cape defines “summer”!

Property Details