Victorian Shelter Island Heights

Rental Registraton #2026-L-006. This lovely iconic 1800’s Heights Victorian sits on a corner with views to “The Grove” with Union Chapel and its beautiful grounds just a stone’s throw away. Restored in 2025 with modern amenities in keeping with the fine character and decor of the home, this three bedroom, two and a half bath classic has all the ingredients for a memorable vacation within Shelter Island Heights. Step into the living room which opens to a dining area toward the rear, with large windows on both sides of the house to maximize natural light. To the right of the living room is a library/den with media and to the left of the dining room is an “L” shaped kitchen with Caesarstone counters and culinary amenities. At the bottom of the steps leading to the second floor is a powder room, and upstairs are two guest rooms that utilize a full bath along the hallway and a primary en suite bedroom with arched doors with park views. Truly one of the most charming homes in the Heights, with easy access to ferry, shops, dining and beach club. Landlord requests no shares.

Property Details