Penelope Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(631) 749-5801
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • Search
    • Residential Listings
    • Land Listings
    • Rental Listings
    • Sold Listings
    • Shelter Island Sold Properties
  • Neighborhoods
  • Buyers
  • Sellers
  • Blog
  • About
    • About
    • Shelter Island Town Information
    • Testimonials
    • Penelope in the News
    • Standard Operating Procedures
    • Support
  • Contact
Home > Listings

Residential Listings

Shelter Island Pondfront with Dual Levels

Shelter Island Pondfront with Dual Levels

Priced at $1,675,000    Beds: 2    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 1488

Set on the gentle slope of a spring-fed pond, this Shelter Island residence, similar in ways to a  ... Property Details

Quiet Shelter Island Renovated Cottage with Arboretum

Quiet Shelter Island Renovated Cottage with Arboretum

Priced at $1,845,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 1 Full, 1 Half    Sq. Feet: 1344

Perched at the top of a gentle driveway on 2.3+/- quiet gated acres in Shelter Island's estate  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Estate Waterfront Compound

Shelter Island Estate Waterfront Compound

Priced at $7,850,000    Beds: 7    Baths: 7.5    Sq. Feet: 4347

A rare offering on Shelter Island, this estate compound includes two distinct homes sold together: a  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Turn-Key Waterfront with Peninsula

Shelter Island Turn-Key Waterfront with Peninsula

Priced at $2,349,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 3312

Set on 1.06 acres with elevated sunrise vistas, this freshly renovated single-story cottage is fully  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Modern Waterfront Sanctuary with Dock and Pool

Shelter Island Modern Waterfront Sanctuary with Dock and Pool

Priced at $4,450,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 4.5    Sq. Feet: 3187

Set on 1.3 private acres on a peninsula at the end of a long driveway, this sleek modern has been  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Shingle Style 1870 Farmhouse near Beach

Shelter Island Shingle Style 1870 Farmhouse near Beach

Priced at $1,865,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 1235

Located just outside Shelter Island Heights, this charming three-story stick-and-shingle style,  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Modernist Gem with Pool and Guest House

Shelter Island Modernist Gem with Pool and Guest House

Priced at $3,600,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 2890

This architecturally distinctive home, inspired by the mid-century California Case Study Houses and  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Cape Cod with Pool near Beach

Shelter Island Cape Cod with Pool near Beach

Priced at $1,795,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 1933

Located within close proximity of association beaches, this fresh and delightfully rambling Cape Cod  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Turn-Key Country Cape

Shelter Island Turn-Key Country Cape

Priced at $1,195,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 1831

This lovingly maintained Cape Cod-style home, built in 1995, is situated on a .7-acre lot and offers  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Charming Classic Heights Traditional

Shelter Island Charming Classic Heights Traditional

Priced at $1,785,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 1985

Located in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this 1880s traditional home was completely restored  ... Property Details

Exquisite Shelter Island Soundfront Beach House with Dock

Exquisite Shelter Island Soundfront Beach House with Dock

Priced at $5,500,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 4.5    Sq. Feet: 2967

This elegant traditional, sited in an inspiring waterfront setting, is a one-of-a-kind, with four  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Ram Island Traditional Close to Preserve

Shelter Island Ram Island Traditional Close to Preserve

Priced at $2,495,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 3.5    Sq. Feet: 3397

Located on a quiet lane on Ram Island in Shelter Island adjacent to 40 acre preserve, this tasteful  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Fabulous Waterfront with Dock and Pool

Shelter Island Fabulous Waterfront with Dock and Pool

Priced at $2,895,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 1870

Located in a popular boating area, this clean, contemporary waterfront is all about sun, fun and  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Heights Classic 1874 Traditional

Shelter Island Heights Classic 1874 Traditional

Priced at $1,295,000    Beds: 5    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 1970

Nestled in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this delightful 1874 classic is within close  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Stylish Cape with Pool and Deeded Dock Access

Shelter Island Stylish Cape with Pool and Deeded Dock Access

Priced at $2,350,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 3.5    Sq. Feet: 2200

Built in 2006, this classic traditional home resting on .70 acres is located on a quiet corner in  ... Property Details

Shelter Island 1886 Lily Pond Victorian

Shelter Island 1886 Lily Pond Victorian

Priced at $1,995,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 2323

Located on 2.24 acres and comprised of two separate lots: 21 Congdon with .68 acres and home, and 23  ... Property Details

Shelter Island 1832 Restored Classic with Pool

Shelter Island 1832 Restored Classic with Pool

Priced at $1,950,000    Beds: 5    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 2300

This classic Shelter Island 1832 Cape Cod was recently renovated by its designer-owners and is the  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Unparalleled Peninsula Estate with Pool

Shelter Island Unparalleled Peninsula Estate with Pool

Priced at $17,975,000    Beds: 5    Baths: 5    Sq. Feet: 5447

Tucked away at the end of a hidden, nearly mile-long drive through protected "forever green" land,  ... Property Details

1887 Dering Harbor Village Victorian with Pool and Dock

1887 Dering Harbor Village Victorian with Pool and Dock

Priced at $6,750,000    Beds: 5    Baths: 3.5    Sq. Feet: 4053

This charming, renovated 1887 Victorian is located on a quiet lane on 1.44+/- acres in the Village  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Turn of the Century Waterfront with Dock
Pending

Shelter Island Turn of the Century Waterfront with Dock

Priced at $4,450,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 1.1    Sq. Feet: 1715

Located in one of the most sought after estate sections of Shelter Island, with western facing  ... Property Details

  • 1
  • 2
  • Next Page »

Contact Me

Lets Chat! Contact me with any questions!
Contact

Stay Connected

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
Penelope Moore

Penelope Moore

Since 1998, Penelope has been the driving force and leader in the Shelter Island real estate market, and is the go-to real estate broker for discerning buyers and sellers. She has experienced record-breaking sales in multiple categories over successive years, and her success has been distinguished not just by benchmark sales, but by volume in all categories.

Meet Penelope

Penelope Moore, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

9 Grand Avenue, PO Box 100
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965-0100

(631) 749-5801
(917) 208-5519 Mobile

Contact Penelope

CRS logo
Saunders Realty logo

© 2025 All Rights Reserved  •  Privacy Policy  •  Accessibility Statement