Penelope Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(631) 749-5801
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • Search
    • Residential Listings
    • Land Listings
    • Rental Listings
    • Sold Listings
    • Shelter Island Sold Properties
  • Neighborhoods
  • Buyers
  • Sellers
  • Blog
  • About
    • About
    • Shelter Island Town Information
    • Testimonials
    • Penelope in the News
    • Standard Operating Procedures
    • Support
  • Contact

Shelter Island Sold Properties

Week Ending January 6, 2023

      • Pinto Trust to Pinto Trust (Intra-Family), 9 Seagull Road (700-26-1-15), (R), $1,750,000, On: 10/31/22

Week Ending December 23, 2022

      • Calabro to Webb, 31A Dickerson Drive (700-22-2-23.6), (R), $1,900,000, On: 10/10/22
      • Hensley & Weinstein to Coecies Cottage LLC, 84 North Cartwright Road (700-8-3-13.1), (R), $975,000, On: 10/21/22
      • Hanlon to Hanlon, 12 Shelterlands Path (Partial Interest) (700-19-2-80.13), $300,000, On: 07/20/22
      • Estate of James Hayes to Longview Island Estates LLC, 5 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-3-2-53.1), (R), $1,751,000, On: 10/21/22
      • Elizabeth Cancroft Trust to  Mablekos & Shatken, 3 Country Club Drive (700-3-2-15), (R), $1,550,000, On: 10/21/22
      • Landley Realty Corp to 11 Sunnyside LLC, 11 Sunnyside Avenue (700-7-2-4), (V), $635,000, On: 09/26/22

Week Ending December 16, 2022

      • White to County of Suffolk, Artists Lane (700-22-2-5.12), (V), $2,500,000, On: 09/02/22

Week Ending December 2, 2022

      • Verlaque & Kelly to Loeffler, 12 Terry Drive (700-17-1-66), (R), $2,350,000, On: 07/31/22
      • Barnes to 22 Winthrop LLC, 22 Winthrop Road (700-7-4-42), (R), $828,898, On: 09/28/22
      • 36 New York Ave SI Heights LLC to 36 New York Avenue LLC, 36 New York Avenue (700-6-3-28), (R), $700,000, On: 09/28/22

Week Ending November 25, 2022

      • Baron to Lajqi, 29 Hilo Drive (700-14-2-59), (R), $1,275,000, On: 08/11/22

Week Ending November 11, 2022

      • Larkin to Brown & Bergin, 30 Baldwin Road (700-19-1-78.6), (R), $1,645,000, On: 06/08/22
      • Estate of Jerome Berner to Their House LLC, 14 Baldwin Road (700-19-1-68.1), (R), $1,300,000, On: 08/31/22
      • Dorothy MacFarlane Living Trust to Bocci, 2 Deer Park Lane (700-23-2-15.5), (V), $135,000, On: 10/24/22
      • Allen to Scuglik & Kim, 151 North Ferry Road (700-7-3-40), (R), $3,500,000, On: 07/28/22
      • Murray to SI Peconic LLC, 78 Peconic Avenue (700-25-1-7), (R), $3,350,000, On: 08/02/22
      • Craco to JWRNY LLC, 14 Montclair Avenue (700-22-2-40), (R), $3,250,000, On: 07/01/22

Week Ending November 4, 2022

      • Card to Eddy, Eelans & Eddy, 15 South Midway Road (700-19-1-39), (R), $990,000, On: 08/11/22
      • White 456 LLC to Country of Suffolk, Town of Shelter Island, Artists Lane (700-22-2-5.11), (V), $4,250,000, On: 09/02/22

Week Ending October 28, 2022

      • Estate of Kolina Reiter, 87 North Ferry Road (700-15-1-1), Comm Prop, $2,050,000, On: 06/30/22

Week Ending September 9, 2022

      • Warren & Glasser to Rogan, 15 North Cartwright Road (700-15-4-100), (R), $985,000, On: 04/21/22
      • Matthew Clark Trust & Haberl to Brennan & Amico, 10B Club Drive (700-12-1-29.3), (R), $2,800,000, On: 12/14/21
      • Estate of Carol Aronow to Hugh-Jones, 1 Point Lane (700-1-2-1.6), (R), $2,300,000, On: 08/25/22
      • Harms to Harms (Intra-Family), 55 Cobbetts Lane (700-3-2-49.1), (R), $2,008,000, On: 08/09/22
      • Ronayne & Holliday to Baik & Rodriguez, 40 Dinah Rock Road (700-1-1-28), (R), $1,610,000, On: 06/10/22

Week Ending September 2, 2022

      • Pandion Acquisitions LLC to Torres, Burns Road (700-16-1-5.3), (V), $3,775,000, On: 08/04/22
      • Siegelbaum Trust to Isar River Trust (Mahon – Trustee), 149 Ram Island Drive (700-10-1-14), (R), $9,700,000, On: 08/09/22

Week Ending August 26, 2022

      • Rosenberg to Gooley & Cairns, 4 Great Circle Drive (700-1-1-54), (R), $1,750,000, On: 06/17/22
      • Kanarvogel to Seymour, 39 Stearns Point Road (700-13-2-38), (R), $900,000, On: 06/08/22

Week Ending August 19, 2022

      • Estate of Samuel Suratt & Estate of Judith Hole to Silver Beach Hideaway LLC, 7 White Birch Road (700-25-1-46), (R), $890,000, On: 07/19/22
      • Lind to Foley, 58 Country Club Drive (700-1-2-17), (V), $525,000, On: 06/17/22

Week Ending August 12, 2022

      • Goldberg to Minite & Millspaugh, 10 Bowditch Road (700-14-3-46), (R), $999,000, On: 05/31/22
      • Karsch to Rozos, 1 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-3-2-50), (R), $2,500,000, On: 04/14/22

Week Ending August 5, 2022

      • Pedersen to 64 N Cartwright LLC, 64 North Cartwright Road (700-8-3-60), (R), $1,700,000, On: 06/14/22
      • Billings & Somerville to Bernstein, 4 Wheeler Road (700-22-1-95), (R), $1,865,000, On: 06/28/22
      • Estate of Cecilia Kraus to 166 N Ferry Road LLC, 22 Stearns Point Road (700-13-2-8.1), (V), $1,150,000, On: 06/17/22

Week Ending July 29, 2022

      • Williamson to Sylvester Manor Educational Farm Inc, 82 North Ferry Road (700-8-1-5.3), (R), $2,200,000, On: 06/28/22
      • Staal to Tobin & Skinner, 142F North Ferry Road (700-7-4-73), (R), $1,223,000, On: 02/17/22

Week Ending July 22, 2022

      • Cyr to Walsh, Quail Hedge Lane (700-7-4-77.5), (V), $510,000, On: 06/02/22

Week Ending July 15, 2022

      • Gevis & Kapur to Kapur, 45 South Midway Road (Partial Interest) (700-19-1-23.5), $300,000, On: 05/23/22
      • Tarlow & Carlson to Brown LLC, 25 Nostrand Parkway (700-17-1-7.1), (R), $6,000,000, On: 12/20/21
      • Case to Weaver & Hermo-Weaver, 16 Wesley Avenue (700-5-2-11), (R), $720,000, On: 05/19/22

Week Ending July 8, 2022

      • Estate of William Coleman to Bears Watch LLC, Rocky Point Terrace (700-13-1-4.1), (V), $1,500,000, On: 05/05/22
      • Stroh to JBS33139 LLC, 34 Rocky Point Road (700-13-1-28.1), (V), $445,000, On: 05/26/22

Week Ending July 1, 2022

      • Fotopulos & Masser to Fotopulos, 19 West Neck Road (Partial Interest) (700-14-3-21), (R), $390,000, On: 04/29/22
      • 39 Brander LLC to Davis, 39 Brander Parkway (700-22-1-75.1), (R), $1,565,000, On: 04/04/22

Week Ending June 24, 2022

      • Gillooley to Moorcroft, 23 Lakeview Drive (700-19-2-65), (R), $1,605,000, On: 04/21/22
      • Case to Cranford, 139 North Ferry Road (700-7-3-46), (V), $410,000, On: 05/11/22

Week Ending June 17, 2022

      • Calabro to Marks, 73 North Midway Road (700-14-3-35.5), (R), $1,627,000, On: 04/08/22

Week Ending June 10, 2022

      • Estate of Miles Hoye to Svendby & Cummings, 133 South Midway Road (700-23-2-14), (R), $1,475,000, On: 02/09/22
      • Harris to Taylor, 1 Shorewood Road (700-23-2-27), (V), $520,000, On: 04/06/22
      • Zust to Kaasik, 5 Lake Drive (700-19-1-87.1), (V), $330,000, On: 03/23/22
      • Brady to 25 North Ferry Rd LLC, 25 North Ferry Road (700-15-3-60), Comm Prop, $200,000, On: 10/18/21
      • Monti to Larsen & Viviano, 10 Burro Hall Lane (700-14-2-60.7), (R), $1,400,000, On: 01/12/22
      • Estate of Edwin Langbein to Olinkiewicz, 5 Chase Avenue (700-5-6-16), (R), $415,000, On: 03/25/22
      • Plaintiff: West Coast 2014-7 LLC, Defendant: Deborah Endemann, 3 Spring Garden Avenue (700-5-4-22), (R), Mort Amt: $300,000, Date Recorded: 05/16/22

Week Ending May 27, 2022

      • Eklund to Eklund (Intra-Family), 40 South Ferry Road (700-19-2-106), (R), $809,000, On: 03/01/22
      • Helene & Michel Nespoulous Trust to Water Baux LLC, 183 North Ram Island Drive (700-10-1-37.2), (R), $4,700,000, On: 03/23/22
      • Kesler to Button, 11 White Birch Road (700-25-1-44), (R), $992,500, On: 12/28/21

Week Ending May 13, 2022

      • Jacobs to 4 Sleepy Hollow LLC, 4 Sleepy Hollow Road (700-14-5-10), (R), $975,000, On: 02/22/22
      • SSO Realty Corp to CXR Shelter Island Pharmacy LLC, 19 Grand Avenue (700-5-5-27), Comm Prop, $1,500,000, On: 03/07/22

Week Ending April 29, 2022

      • Scola to Vroom House LLC, 42 Brander Parkway (700-22-1-28), (R), $899,000, On: 03/04/22

Week Ending April 15, 2022

      • Boccuzza & Carbone to Lashine c/o Gary Sher Trust, 114 South Midway Road (700-23-1-38), (V), $35,000, On: 02/18/22

Week Ending April 1, 2022

      • Lenzer to Lenzer (Intra-Family), 19 Congdon Road (700-15-4-59), (R), $520,000, On: 02/10/22
      • Persky to 5 Burro Hall LLC, 5 Burro Hall Lane (700-14-2-60.9), $2,750,000, On: 12/09/21
      • Plaintiff: Wilmington Savings Fund Society FSB, Defendant: TCHAMP LLC, 11 Peconic Avenue (700-21-1-41), (R), Mort Amt: $734,400, Date Recorded: 03/15/22

Week Ending March 25, 2022

      • Sylvester Road Associates LLC to 34 Shelter Associates LLC c/o Bachir Karam, 4 Sylvester Road (701-1-1-22), (R), $6,000,000, On: 12/02/21
      • Giuseppone to 102 Peconic Ave SI LLC, 102 Peconic Avenue (700-25-1-17), (R), $4,900,000, On: 12/10/21
      • Foley & Sapan to Overbrook Real Property (SI) LLC, 16 Clinton Avenue (700-5-3-8), (R), $4,100,000, On: 11/24/21
      • Geraldine Weiss Trust to Aheran, 18 Great Circle Drive (700-1-1-61), (R), $995,000, On: 02/03/22
      • Landley Realty Corp to Gurdak, 2 Serpentine Drive (700-14-1-6.2), (V), $630,000, On: 02/03/22
      • Barcia to Mallin, Wheeler Road (700-22-1-72.2), (V), $545,000, On: 12/23/21
      • Case to Seddio, 139A North Ferry Road (700-7-3-45.4), (V), $410,000, On: 01/12/22
      • McGinnis to Sambol, 5 Grand Avenue (700-5-5-20.1), (V), $360,000, On: 12/13/21
      • Tolman & Shannon to Shannon, 7 Petticoat Lane (Partial Interest) (700-22-1-79), (R), $245,000, On: 01/24/22
      • Plaintiff: Reverse Mortgage Solutions Inc, Defendant: Estate of Owen Rice, 52 South Ferry Road (700-19-2-114), (R), Mort Amt: $544,185, Date Recorded: 02/25/22

Week Ending March 11, 2022

      • Svendby & Cummings to Smillie, 16 Margarets Drive (700-18-2-41), (R), $4,500,000, On: 01/11/22
      • Estate of Judy Bennett to Big Ram LLC, 2 South Ram Island Drive (700-10-1-7.2), (R), On: 11/18/21
      • Rogers to Veksler, 13 Hilo Drive (700-14-2-86.3), (R), $850,000, On: 10/07/21

Week Ending March 4, 2022

      • Stack Venture Partners LLC to Gardiners SI LLC, 66 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-1-2-64), (R), $2,900,000, On: 12/23/21
      • Baron to Clark, 5 Brander Parkway (700-17-1-28), (R), $850,000, On: 12/21/21
      • Johnson to Tuthill Drive Holdings LLC, 17 Tuthill Drive (700-11-1-7.1), (V), $650,000, On: 01/28/22

Week Ending February 25, 2022

      • Anglin to CXR Shelter Island Heights Marina LLC, 171B North Ferry Road (700-7-4-82.1), Comm Prop, $3,200,000, On: 12/17/21

Week Ending January 28, 2022

      • Joseph Salsedo Trust to 2 Sleepy Hollow Rd SI LLC, 2 Sleepy Hollow Road (700-14-5-11), (R), $800,000, On: 11/23/21
      • Lanto & Bowers to McGloin, 5 Mimosa Place (700-17-1-72), (R), $905,000, On: 11/16/21

Week Ending January 21, 2022

      • Frederic Gannon Trust to Guillemin & Stern, 17 Point Lane (700-1-2-1.14), (R), $3,200,000, On: 12/08/21
      • Miller to Dorment & Porcaro, 13 Clinton Avenue (700-5-2-35.3), (R), $1,310,000, On: 11/23/21
      • McClellan Family Trust to O’Connor, 59 West Neck Road (700-14-2-10), (R), $950,000, On: 10/19/21
      • Kronwitt to Brooks, 10 Sylvan Road (700-7-3-11), (R), $840,000, On: 12/15/21

Week Ending January 14, 2022

      • Baddeley to Jamal, 133 South Ferry Road (700-24-1-46), (R), $1,584,706, On: 10/22/21
      • Williams to Hansen, 1 Strawberry Lane (700-19-2-16.2), (V), $340,000, On: 11/15/21
      • Weiner to 1 Wheeler Lane Company LLC, 1 Wheeler Road (700-22-1-110), (R), $4,700,000, On: 12/10/21
      • Estate of Betsy Jacobson to Lyons, 140 West Neck Road (700-17-1-44.10), (R), $2,700,000, On: 12/21/21
      • Ellinger to Canada, 33 Westmoreland Drive (700-18-1-45.1), (R), $2,525,000, On: 11/04/21
      • Baker to Carroll, 16 Harbor Lane (701-1-2-10.1), (R), $6,500,000, On: 11/03/21

Week Ending January 7, 2022

      • Sher & Lashine to Lashine, 116 South Midway Road (Partial Interest) (700-23-1-39), (R), $186,852, On: 12/15/20
      • Binder to Salt House SI LLC, 15 Montclair Avenue (700-22-2-60), (R), $4,900,000, On: 11/15/21
      • Kast to Leon West Neck LLC, 84 West Neck Road (700-14-1-58.7), (R), $895,000, On: 10/06/21

Week Ending December 31, 2021

      • Carr to Gushareil Estate LLC, 6 Duvall Road (700-15-3-91), (R), $500,000, On: 11/29/21
      • Beach Channel Holdings LLC to Spitzer, 29 Sunnyside Avenue (700-6-2-22), (V), $479,990, On: 11/16/21
      • Stark to Stark, 20 Clinton Avenue (Partial Interest) (700-5-3-6), (R), $279,000, On: 10/28/21

Week Ending December 24, 2021

      • Montella & Callan to Midway DP LLC, 24 South Midway Road (700-19-1-5), (R), $2,608,125, On: 10/04/21
      • Wong & Flanagan to Rohrer, 56 Lake Drive (700-19-1-113), (R), $1,395,000, On: 10/29/21
      • Murphy & Klein to Murphy (Intra-Family), 8 Chequit Avenue (700-5-3-3), (R), $1,150,000, On: 11/26/21

Week Ending December 17, 2021

      • Matz to 10 Tarkettle Rd SI LLC, 10 Tarkettle Road (700-23-1-5), (R), $2,750,000, On: 10/20/21
      • Estate of Lynn Franklin to Binder, 15 Baldwin Road (700-19-2-13), (R), $1,150,000, On: 10/21/21
      • Mattson to Wong & Flanagan, 70 South Ferry Road (700-19-2-69), (R), $720,000, On: 10/29/21
      • Caccese to Rogers, 5 Tuthill Drive (700-11-1-2), (V), $920,000, On: 10/22/21
      • Hindin to Wagner, 148D North Ferry Road (700-7-4-57-2), (R), $1,380,000, On: 09/08/21

Week Ending December 10, 2021

      • Wells to Andrew Marks Trust, 7 Lari Lane (700-8-3-5.13), (R), $3,750,000, On: 09/29/21
      • Gaffney to Casale, 5 Osprey Lane (700-23-2-68.1), (R), $1,250,000, On: 09/30/21
      • Lavarello to Adamo & Scaraglino, 5 Heritage Drive (700-19-2-113.14), (R), $1,200,000, On: 10/15/21
      • Romano Realty Holding Company LLC to Bucci, 104 South Ferry Road (700-23-2-95.7), (V), $550,000, On 08/31/21
      • Blumfield to Carey, 1 Brander Parkway (700-17-1-29.2), (R), $1,812,500, On: 09/29/21
      • Harkins to LoMangino, 6 Behringer Lane (700-14-1-58.2), (V), $400,000, On: 07/01/21

Week Ending December 3, 2021

      • Carey to Wards Point Holdings LLC, 3 Shorewood Court (700-26-1.1.3), (R), $5,250,000, On: 08/05/21
      • Clark & Reylek to Landfall Properties LLC, 47L South Ferry Road (700-20-1-16), (R), $2,251,000, On: 08/11/21
      • Dickerson Family Trust to Ivansson & Day, 13 Tarkettle Road (700-23-1-25), (R), $1,800,000, On: 10/14/21
      • Dougherty to Fairweather Forest LLC, 84A North Cartwright Road (700-8-3-12), (V), $375,000, On: 09/21/21
      • Pridwin Hotel Limited to Cape Pridwin Owner LLC, 81 Shore Road (700-13-1-20), Comm Prop $804,000, On: 09/03/21
      • Estate of Linda Holmes to Avast LLC, 30 Dinah Rock Road (700-1-1-23), (R), $790,000, On: 06/15/21

Week Ending November 19, 2021

      • Barcia to 3 Strawberry Lane LLC, 3 Strawberry Lane (700-19-2-19), (R), $1,323,200, On: 09/23/21
      • Robertson Family LLC to Dunne, 18 Tuthill Drive (700-11-2-16), (R), $3,250,000, On: 09/14/21
      • Estate of Amy Robertson to Dunne, 20 Tuthill Drive (700-11-2-17) (V), $250,000, On: 09/14/21

Week Ending November 12, 2021

      • Harris to Villafuerte & Alfaro, 7 Lakeview Drive (700-19-2-41.3), (R), $999,000, On: 09/03/21
      • Toubassy to Langham & Girma, 47 Shore Road (700-13-2-11), (V), $1,641,000, On: 09/02/21

Week Ending November 5, 2021

      • Roe to Roe, 5 Westmoreland Drive (700-18-1-32.1), (R), $1,984,506, On: 05/26/21
      • Boylan to Hall, 10 Grand Avenue (700-5-6-5), (R), $1,875,000, On: 09/17/21
      • Seddio to Vaszauskas, 11 Hillside Drive (700-14-2-53), (V), $650,000, On: 07/19/21
      • Kaufman to Conrad, 24 Dinah Rock Road (700-1-1-20), (R), $1,350,000, On: 08/10/21
      • 165 North Ferry LLC to Murphy, 7 Grand Avenue (700-5-5-21), (R), $750,000
      • Eicke to White Oak Estates LLC, 19 N Ferry Road (700-15-3-93), (R), $810,000, On: 07/06/21
      • McGuire Trust to Mehtani, 9 Willow Pond Lane (700-19-2-112), (V). $580,000, On: 07/02/21

Week Ending October 29, 2021

      • 10 Lari Lane LLC to Lari Lane LP, 10 Lari Lane (700-8-3-5.12), (R), $11,575,000, On: 09/20/21

Week Ending October 22, 2021

      • Hassman to Giallorenzi, 91 South Ferry Road (700-23-3-2), (V), $460,000, On: 06/18/21

Week Ending October 15, 2021

      • Estate of George Blados to Schneider, 21B West Neck Road (700-14-3-19.2), (R), $840,000, On: 08/10/21
      • Field to Donahue, 31 Saint Marys Road (700-15-3-14), (R), $742,000, On: 08/10/21
      • Zeuschner to 2 Cobbetts Lane LLC, 2 Cobbetts Lane (700-7-7-31), (R), $3,495,000, On: 09/08/21
      • Raff to Simmons, 1 Sylvan Road (700-14-3-6.1), (R), $1,575,000, On: 07/08/21
      • Becker to Yim, 94 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-1-2-51), (R), $1,300,000, On: 06/30/21

Week Ending October 8, 2021

      • Sugar to Destaing & Amiri, 55 Smith Street (700-18-3-75.5), (R), $795,000, On: 07/30/21
      • Estate of Dianne McGayhey to Hensley, 84 North Cartwright Road (700-8-3-13.1), (R), $735,000, On: 08/27/21
      • Estate of Martha Williams to Malin, 10 Bluff Avenue (700-5-4-3), (R), $2,400,000, On: 08/06/21
      • Karpeh to Martha Cline Trust (Sopko – Trustee), 4 Quaker Path (700-8-2-6), (R), $1,400,000, On: 05/23/21
      • Rush to Primrose MKB LLC, 13 Primrose Place (700-3-2-37), (R), $1,350,000, On: 07/02/21

Week Ending October 1, 2021

      • Eicke to White Oak Estates LLC, 19 North Ferry Road (700-15-3-93), Comm Bus, $810,000, On: 07/06/21
      • Mary McGuire Trust to Mehtani, 9 Willow Pond Lane (700-19-2-112), (V), $580,000, On: 06/28/21
      • Leon to Estreich, 23 Sunnyside Avenue (700-6-2-18.2), (R), $2,200,000, On: 08/05/21
      • 165 North Ferry LLC to Murphy, 7 Grand Avenue (700-5-5-21), (R), $750,000, On: 03/25/21

Week Ending September 17, 2021

      • Pandion Acquisitions LLC to Greenwald, Burns Road (700-16-1-5.2), $3,250,000, On: 07/27/21
      • Estate of Rosemary Sanwald to Smith, 45 North Midway Road (700-14-3-68), (R), $574,000, On: 05/28/21

Week Ending September 10, 2021

      • Montgomery to 30LittleRamIsland LLC, 30 Little Ram Island Drive (700-9-3-29), (R), $4,900,000, On: 04/21/21
      • Campbell to Walker, 3 Bluff Avenue (700-5-4-26.1), (R), $2,575,000, On: 05/24/21
      • Shearer to Defouw, 11 East Brander Parkway (700-22-1-150), (R), $2,450,000, On: 07/15/21
      • Soyars to Mirando, 4 Worthy Way (700-17-2-24), (R), $895,000, On: 08/02/21
      • Cabinet Realty Corp to First SMPD LLC, 8 Fred’s Lane (700-18-2-61), (V), $515,000, On: 07/27/21

Week Ending September 3, 2021

      • 32 St Marys Road LLC to Brock & Bury, 32 Saint Marys Road (700-15-4-11), (R), $1,250,000, On: 03/18/21
      • Kaasik to Leon Real Estate Group LLC, 1 South Ferry Road (700-15-4-68), Comm Prop, $1,225,000, On: 07/12/21
      • Grella to Barbaria, 13 Hillside Drive (700-14-2-54), (V), $320,000, On: 05/28/21

Week Ending August 27, 2021

      • Frances Johnson Trust to Silver Aerodrome LLC, 22 Burns Road (700-15-4-102.2), (R), $785,000, On: 06/18/21
      • Frances Johnson Trust to Silver Aerodrome LLC, Burns Road (700-15-4-102.1), (V), $500,000, On: 06/18/21
      • Estate of Dora Wieder to Wechsler & Wieder (Intra-Family), 6 Pheasant Lane (700-26-1-4), (R), $300,000, On: 05/18/21
      • Gleacher to Lotus Land LLC, 24 East Brander Parkway (700-25-1-53), (R), $2,845,000, On: 07/22/21
      • Kukacka to DeSanctis, 22 West Neck Road (700-14-3-4), (R), $675,000, On: 08/03/21
      • Zoumas to Billings & Somerville, 4 Wheeler Road (700-22-1-95), (V), $535,000, On: 07/15/21
      • Benson to Randolph, 4 Tims Trail (700-17-2-64), (V), $329,000, On: 05/18/21

Week Ending August 20, 2021

      • Manafort to Knight & Chobor, 57 North Midway Road (700-14-3-41.2), (R), $675,000, On: 05/25/21
      • Harabaglia to Gabbay, 22 Dinah Rock Road (700-3-2-6), (V), $340,000, On: 05/11/21

Week Ending August 13, 2021

      • Walsh to SI Homes LLC, 2 Sunshine Road (700-19-1-52), (R), $800,000, On: 06/21/21
      • Hickey to O’Brien, 22 Country Club Drive (700-3-2-28), (R), $1,119,000, On: 04/21/21
      • Estate of Cecelia Kraus to Blanco & Cerdas, 3 Glynn Drive (700-17-1-70), (R), $755,000, On: 02/25/21

Week Ending August 6, 2021

      • McLean to Dugan, 37 Tuthill Drive (700-12-1-6), (R), $2,100,000, On: 04/25/21
      • Plaintiff: Deutsche Bank, Defendant: Reiter, 11 Fox Hollow Run (700-19-2-113.9), (R), Mort Amt: $728,951, Date Recorded: 07/08/21

Week Ending July 30, 2021

      • Minder & Gessner to Sun Is Shining LLC, 32 South Midway Road (700-19-1-8), (R), $900,000, On: 05/24/21
      • Mary Trikoupis Trust to Russell & Krizelman, 12 Peconic Avenue (700-21-1-16), (R), $3,500,000, On: 04/29/21
      • Ruth & Victor Nussenzweig Trust to McPhail, 9 Point Lane (700-1-2-1.10), (R), $1,470,000, On: 04/06/21

Week Ending July 23, 2021

      • Kia Pedersen Trust to Pedersen (Intra-Family), 64 North Cartwright Road (700-8-3-60), $918,500, On: 04/21/21
      • Kia Pedersen Trust to Pedersen (Intra-Family), 66 North Cartwright Road (700-8-3-59), (V), $71,500, On: 04/21/21
      • O’Shea to Young, 47 New York Avenue (700-6-4-6.3), (R), $1,358,000, On: 05/19/21

Week Ending July 16, 2021

      • Seddio to McCoubrey & Nagourney, 5 Hilo Drive (700-14-2-26), (R), $1,100,000, On: 06/17/21
      • Garcia to Hommert, 18 Country Club Drive (700-3-2-26), (V), $685,000, On: 04/23/21

Week Ending July 9, 2021

      • Estate of Margaret Stankevich to Alden Construction Corp, 22 Locust Point Road (701-1-3-14.2), (V), $1,375,000, On: 03/18/21
      • Beach Shack LLC to Valentino, 8 Osprey Lane (700-23-2-63.1), (R), $2,050,000, On: 04/29/21
      • Clark to Clark (Intra-Family), 41 North Midway Road (700-14-3-70.1), (R), $775,000, On: 06/01/21
      • Jackson to Hoffmann, 8 North Ferry Road (700-15-3-80.4), (R), $695,000, On: 05/20/21
      • Heimann to Boylan, 10 Grand Avenue (700-5-6-5), (R), $1,835,000, On: 04/29/21

Week Ending June 25, 2021

      • Sherman to 18 Bowditch Road LLC, 18 Bowditch Road (700-14-3-53.6), (R), $850,000, On: 02/05/21
      • Yang to Jayaraman & Mussche, 33 Country Club Drive (700-1-1-96), (R), $1,880,000, On: 04/29/21
      • Lenderking to Eichenberger, 7 Spring Garden Avenue, (700-5-4-24), (R), $1,450,000, On: 05/18/21

Week Ending June 18, 2021

      • LaSalle to Sengulen, 25 Lakeview Drive (700-19-2-64), (R), $1,400,000, On: 05/18/21

Week Ending June 11, 2021

      • Miller to Harms, 13A Westmoreland Drive (700-18-1-35.2), (R), $3,260,000, On: 03/08/21
      • Hommert to DeCamp, 56 West Neck Road (700-14-1-36), (R), $3,100,000, On: 04/14/21
      • Hevia to Ringel & Zusman, 4 Crescent Way (700-1-1-84), (R), $1,390,000, On: 04/09/21
      • Pagliaro to Pollack & O’Sullivan, 36 Stearns Point Road (700-13-2-14.1), (V), $575,000, On: 02/05/21

Week Ending June 4, 2021

      • Grabelsky to Joseph & Scheerlinck, 6 Sandpiper Road (700-23-1-45), (R), $1,100,000, On: 02/26/21
      • 29 West Neck Road LLC to SH 29 Westneck LLC, 29 West Neck Road (700-14-3-9.1), Comm Prop, $950,000, On: 03/05/21
      • EFLF LLC to Wood, 19 Strawberry Lane (700-19-2-35), (V), $285,000, On: 01/29/21
      • ZV Shelter LLC to Bootsie SI LLC, 85 Shore Road (700-13-1-18), (V), $2,750,000, On: 03/10/21
      • Lipsyte to SH 29 Westneck LLC, 15 Stearns Point Road (700-14-1-42.2), (V), $300,000, On: 03/08/21

Week Ending May 28, 2021

      • Egan to Neckles, 7 Dering Woods Road (701-1-3-21.4), (V), $550,000, On: 04/20/21
      • Clark Capital LP to Pops Point LLC, 20D North Cartwright Road (700-16-2-2), $1,500,000, On: 04/19/21
      • Wein to Shelter Island Ventures LLC, 59 North Ferry Road (700-15-2-1), Comm Prop, $775,000, On: 04/19/21
      • Chowaniec to Johnston & Salter, 8 Hay Beach Road (700-1-2-8), (R), $1,335,000, On: 05/03/21
      • Hallman to 5 Wade Road LLC, 5 Wade Road (700-8-2-33), (R), $950,000, On: 04/01/21

Week Ending May 21, 2021

      • Buxton to Ferrara, 3 South Cartwright Road (700-15-4-134.5), (V), $469,000, On: 03/17/21
      • Hunt & Truelove to 2 Jaspa Road LLC, 2 Jaspa Road (700-15-2-4), (V), $300,000, On: 03/18/21
      • Lang to Martucci, 32 Country Club Drive (700-1-2-30), (R), $1,085,000, On: 04/02/21

Week Ending May 14, 2021

      • Loeffler to Places to Dream LLC, 189 Ram Island Drive (700-10-1-37.7), (R), $4,995,000, On: 03/01/21
      • Castle & Sherman-Castle to JDMRA LLC, 34 Country Club Drive (700-1-2-29), (V), $440,000, On: 12/23/20
      • Brennan to Brennan & Bartolomeo (Intra-Family), 5 Worthy Way (700-17-2-39), $280,000, On: 05/07/20
      • Plaintiff: CIT Bank, Defendant: King, 98 South Ferry Road (700-23-2-94), (R), Mort Amt: $938,250, Date Recorded: 04/22/21

Week Ending May 7, 2021

      • Richardson to Plump, 7 Apple Orchard Lane (700-26-1-1.1), (R), $9,100,000, On: 03/16/21
      • Johns to English & Virtue, 6G Hager Road (700-18-3-48), (R), $1,650,000, On: 04/01/21
      • Gordon & Pelagia Madore Trust to Calabro, 73 North Midway Road (700-14-3-35.5), (R), $1,385,000, On: 11/13/20
      • Cynar & Napolitano to Hawthorne, 5 Peppermill Lane (700-19-2-80.20), (R), $1,345,000, On: 04/06/21
      • Uncle Chickens LLC to Ronzoni, 157 North Ferry Road (700-7-3-39), (R), $1,390,000, On: 11/12/20
      • Otazu to 3 Wade Road LLC, 3 Wade Road (700-8-2-34), (R), $812,000, On: 01/22/21
      • Grella to Sampson, 17 Hilo Drive (700-14-2-38), (V), $400,000, On: 03/17/21

Week Ending April 30, 2021

      • Mangiarotti to Kolby, 1 Lilliput Lane (700-21-1-57), (R), $926,000, On: 03/23/21

Week Ending April 23, 2021

      • Smith & Romano to Schwartz & Quon, 2 Hagar Road (700-18-3-42), (R), $2,200,000, On: 03/05/21
      • Roggie Trust to Maurer, 7 Dickerson Drive (700-18-3-37), (R), $1,275,000, On: 03/26/21
      • Hathaway Realty Corp to Rams Head Inn LLC, 108 Ram Island Drive (700-10-1-7.9), Comm Prop, $7,590,000, On: 03/15/21
      • Miller & Piersol Partners LLC to Peconic SI LLC, 51 Peconic Avenue (700-25-1-35), (R), $1,350,000, On: 01/17/21
      • Hoffacker & Herzog to Herzog, 5 Hillside Drive (Partial Interest) (700-14-2-50), (R), $275,000, On: 01/29/21

Week Ending April 16, 2021

      • Harris to Swedlow & Caceres, Sleepy Hollow Road (700-14-5-7.1), (V), $535,000, On: 02/06/21

Week Ending April 9, 2021

      • Brownyard to Lynch, 24 Ram Island Road (700-8-3-35), (R), $975,000, On: 01/11/21
      • Nape to Deringcircle LLC, 102 South Ferry Road (700-23-2-95.9), (V), $600,000, On: 12/22/20
      • Benson to Reynoso & Hof, 2 Tims Trail (700-17-2-63), (R), $860,000, On: 12/09/20
      • Estate of Joseph Houston to Lupo, 8 Ole Buck Run (700-17-2-32), (R), $750,000, On: 01/06/21
      • Plaintiff: US Bank, Defendant: Mulligan, 5 Marc Street (700-15-4-16), Mort Amt: $288,000, Date Recorded: 03/23/21

Week Ending April 2, 2021

      • King to Guillemin, Martinez & Majdisova, 6 Marc Street (700-15-4-30), (R), $685,000, On: 01/13/21
      • Coyle to Keating & Marra, 142D Orchard Road (700-7-4-75), (R), $585,000, On: 09/24/20
      • Ramsay tp Zoumas, 4 Wheeler Road (700-22-1-95), (V), $430,000, On: 12/21/20

Week Ending March 26, 2021

      • Barker to 3 Dering Woods LLC, 3 Dering Woods Lane (701-1-3-16.3), (V), $560,000, On: 01/18/21
      • Estate of Jeanne Compton to Walker & Meech, 7 Little Ram Island Drive (700-9-3-17), (R), $3,175,000, On: 01/05/21
      • First SMPD LLC to Stromberg, 9 Margarets Drive (700-18-2-67), $2,795,000, On: 12/29/20
      • English & Virtue to 6 Johnston Road LLC, 6 Johnston Road (700-8-2-50), (R), $675,000, On: 02/25/21

Week Ending March 19, 2021

      • Kusner to Bean & Johnson, 58 Lake Drive (700-23-1-32.1), (R), $1,610,000, On: 12/15/20
      • Ben-Susan to 23 South Midway LLC, 23 South Midway Road (700-19-1-32.2), (R), $960,000, On: 11/27/20
      • Trust to Manafort, 57 North Midway Road (700-14-3-41.2), (R), $615,000, On: 01/20/21
      • Levine & White to Brown, 140 North Ram Island Drive (700-10-1-36.12), (R), $2,681,250, On: 02/17/21
      • David Heiman Trust to Eelens & Eddy, 8 Quaker Path (700-8-2-8), (R), $1,050,000, On: 01/15/21
      • Dunbar to Winitzer, 53 West Neck Road (700-14-2-7.15), (R), $880,000, On: 11/18/20

Week Ending March 12, 2021

      • Lang to Waldbauer, 6 Community Drive (700-14-2-18), (R), $795,000, On: 02/05/21
      • Ulrich to Lang, 12 Wade Road (700-8-2-40), (V), $220,000, On: 02/09/21

Week Ending March 5, 2021

      • Thompson to Thompson & Mannix, 7 Tower Hill Avenue (Partial Interest) (700-6-4-2), (R), $220,000, On: 01/15/21

Week Ending February 26, 2021

      • Estate of Jennette Williams to Beagleman Holdings LLC, 85 Ram Island Drive (700-9-2-5), (R), $4,700,000, On: 11/20/20
      • JPMorgan Chase Bank to Tam & Loftus-Hills, 169 Ram Island Drive (700-10-1-20), (R), $2,580,000, On: 01/19/21
      • Estate of Geraldine Cunningham to Fotopoulos & Masser, 11 Tims Trail (700-18-1-6), (R), $675,000, On: 01/05/21

Week Ending February 19, 2021

      • GYL Inc to Aufrichtig, 13 Sunshine Road (700-19-1-70.2), (R), $1,400,000, On: 11/17/20
      • Nathan Trynin Trust to Coppens, 32 Little Ram Island Road (700-9-3-30), (R), $3,100,000, On: 12/16/20
      • Nuti to Rosamilia, 22 New York Avenue (700-6-4-18), (R), $1,275,000, On: 11/22/20
      • Feinman to Rush, 13 Primrose Place (700-3-2-37), (R), $980,000, On: 11/13/20

Week Ending February 12, 2021

      • Ryder to Barber & Berkule, 8 Gardiner Way (701-1-2-14.1), (R), $3,500,000, On: 11/10/20
      • Pontone to Israel, 22 Merkel Lane (700-24-1-30), (R), $3,850,000, On: 12/03/20
      • Fotopulos & Zitzmann to Fotopulos & Masser, 19 West Neck Road (Partial Interest) (700-14-3-21), $331,995, On: 10/21/20
      • Coles Shelter Island Trust to 42 Gardiners Bay LLC, 42 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-1-2-73.4), (R), $10,250,000, On: 11/02/20
      • Shelter Island Properties LLC to 40 Gardiners Bay Drive LLC, 40 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-1-2-74), (V), $1,250,000, On: 11/02/20
      • Coles to 38 Gardiners Bay LLC, 38 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-1-2-75), (V), $1,250,000, On: 11/02/20

Week Ending February 5, 2021

      • Pond to LaTorre, 6 West Thomas Street (700-15-2-23), (R), $685,000, On: 11/24/20

Week Ending January 29, 2021

      • Ben-Susan to 23A South Midway Road LLC, 23A South Midway Road (700-19-1.32.1), (V), $840,000, On: 11/27/20
      • Bailey Family Trust to McBryan, 16 Bowditch Road (700-14-3-48), (R), $599,000, On: 10/15/20
      • Clark to White Oak Estates LLC, 74 North Ferry Road (700-15-3-1.3), Comm Prop, $575,000, On: 11/19/20
      • Vapnek Living Trust to Kasowitz, 31 Westmoreland Drive (700-18-1.46.1), (R), $3,750,000, On: 09/22/20
      • Singleton to Ausseil & Nespoulous, 22 Peconic Avenue (700-21-1-20), (R), $3,600,000, On: 12/15/20
      • Chadwick to Levinson, 148B North Ferry Road (700-7-4-56), (R), $2,200,000, On: 11/06/20
      • Herdland to Adler & Berton, 1 Valley Road (700-14-2-55), (R), $1,349,000, On: 12/10/20
      • Drake to Gonzalez & Daly, 33 New York Avenue (700-7-5-1.1), (R), $885,000, On: 11/10/20

Week Ending January 22, 2021

      • Plantiff: Deutsche Bank, Defendant: Pfriender, 23 Osprey Road (700-23-2-78), (R), Mort Amt: $1,100,000, Date Recorded: 01/08/21

Week Ending January 15, 2021

      • Linda Adams Trust to Birman & Gubert, 6 South Street (701-1-3-18), (R), $745,000, On: 12/18/20
      • Tyree to Singaporewalla & Dangerfield, 46 Lake Drive (700-19-1-109), (R), $1,175,000, On: 11/11/20
      • Pate & Taylor to Agger & Burton, 15 East Thomas Street (700-15-3-35), (R), $1,155,000, On: 10/02/20
      • Corl to 5 Winthrop LLC, 5 Winthrop Road (700-7-4-10), (R), $9,000,000, On: 10/13/20
      • Alli to Gimme Shelter Island LLC, 82 Gardiners Bay Drive (700-1-2-56), (R), $2,800,000, On: 12/21/20
      • Foley to Aaltonen, 50 Dinah Rock Road (70-1-1-33), (R), $2,475,000, On: 12/21/20
      • Godsall to Gold & Kosow, 152 North Ferry Road (700-7-4-55.3), (R), $1,482,000, On: 11/19/20
      • Estate of Trudy Haralabatos to R & B of Shelter Island LLC, 8 Hillside Drive (700-14-2-47), (V), $345,000, On: 10/19/20

Week Ending January 8, 2021

      • PITW Family LP to Ashner, 26 Harbor Lane (701-1-2-4.1), (R), $3,650,000, On: 10/16/20
      • Kingsbury to Svendby & Cummings, 10 Thompson Road (700-24-1-24), (R), $1,525,000, On: 11/10/20
      • Brown to Albert & Harries, 5 Quail Run (700-19-2-113.22), (R), $1,070,000, On: 12/01/20
      • Fedro Family Trust to Wojciechowski, 8 Burns Road (700-15-4-8), (R), $435,000, On: 09/04/20

Week Ending January 1, 2021

      • Rubin to Wong & Flanigan, 56 Lake Drive (700-19-1-113), (R), $850,000, On: 11/03/20
      • O’Connor & Casertano to Tic & Tac LLC, 5 Nostrand Parkway (700-17-1-12), (R), $7,500,000, On: 10/06/20
      • Simarg LLC to Goodson, 14 Margarets Drive (700-18-2-40), (R), $2,825,000, On: 11/07/20
      • Schulze Trust to Rosenberg, 18 Margarets Drive (700-18-2-42),(R), $2,200,000, On: 11/17/20
      • Quakers Path LLC to Johnson, 5 Quaker Path (700-8-2-4), (R), $1,700,000, On: 11/18/20
      • DeStefano to Diaz & Correa, 13 Dinah Rock Road (700-3-2-4), (R), $895,000, On: 11/25/20

ContactMe

  • Any questions?
  • I'm happy to help!
Contact

What's YourHome Worth?

Find Out

Categories

  • General
  • Home Buying Tips
  • Home Selling Tips
  • Housing Market Conditions
  • Mortgage Tips
  • Penelope In the News
  • Real Estate News
  • Shelter Island Living
  • Shelter Island Market Reports
  • Shelter Island Rentals

Client Testimonials

"You know the market better than anyone on that island. You are the only one I trust out there to sell my home. As always, thanks for the excellent counsel... continued"
- Recommendation from K.K. New York, NY
View All

Contact Me

Lets Chat! Contact me with any questions!
Contact

Stay Connected

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
Penelope Moore

Penelope Moore

Since 1998, Penelope has been the driving force and leader in the Shelter Island real estate market, and is the go-to real estate broker for discerning buyers and sellers. She has experienced record-breaking sales in multiple categories over successive years, and her success has been distinguished not just by benchmark sales, but by volume in all categories.

Meet Penelope

Penelope Moore, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

9 Grand Avenue, PO Box 100
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965-0100

(631) 749-5801
(917) 208-5519 Mobile

Contact Penelope

CRS logo
Saunders Realty logo

© 2023 All Rights Reserved  •  Privacy Policy  •  Accessibility Statement