Sold Listings

Located on .62 acres two blocks from a sandy, sunset beach 4 Worthy Way lives up to its street name!  ... Property Details

This level .62 acre vacant property is located within easy distance to western facing sound front  ... Property Details

Located at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac near Wades Beach, this immaculate mid-century modern is  ... Property Details

Tucked away from view, behind established holly and ivy covered picket fences, 31 St Marys Road is a  ... Property Details

Set on 1.4 acres, this charming farmhouse was built by Remington Havens, a farmer and miller.  ... Property Details

Located within close proximity to western facing, sunset beach and preserve, and set within a grove  ... Property Details

Set in one of the first established areas of Shelter Island, called "Eeltown", known for its vibrant  ... Property Details

Bordering Westmoreland Farm, this spacious traditional with privet privacy hedges is completely  ... Property Details

This Shelter Island retreat with an exquisite 21'x42' Gunite, wifi-enabled luxury heated pool is  ... Property Details

This stylish farmhouse, located just outside the Heights on two acres with creek access, has just  ... Property Details

Classic farmhouse style built in 2003 on a shy acre offers nearly 3000sf of living space with slices  ... Property Details

Located within close proximity to sandy beach, this bright and cheery ranch offers wonderful  ... Property Details

Targeted completion date mid September 2020! Located a half block from Hiberry Lane beach on 1.1  ... Property Details

Located on a quiet corner with slices of water views and established plantings, this level .87 acres  ... Property Details

This meticulously maintained cedar shingled cottage is currently the only completely turn-key home  ... Property Details

Bordering preserve and within close proximity of sandy beach with sunsets, this handsome cape is  ... Property Details

Located on a quiet lane within close proximity of the North Ferry, Shelter Island Yacht Club, shops  ... Property Details

Sited on one acre, tucked on a slight hill overlooking West Neck Bay, this contemporary offers a  ... Property Details

Located on 1.06+/- acres in a park-like setting within close proximity to ferry and popular beaches,  ... Property Details

Located off the beaten path, bordering Mashomack Preserve, this quiet contemporary has just been  ... Property Details