Penelope Moore
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(631) 749-5801
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • Search
    • Residential Listings
    • Land Listings
    • Rental Listings
    • Sold Listings
    • Shelter Island Sold Properties
  • Neighborhoods
  • Buyers
  • Sellers
  • Blog
  • About
    • About
    • Shelter Island Town Information
    • Testimonials
    • Penelope in the News
    • Standard Operating Procedures
    • Support
  • Contact
Home > Listings > Page 2

Sold Listings

Shelter Island Tranquil, Grassy Acreage
Sold

Shelter Island Tranquil, Grassy Acreage

Priced at $795,000    Beds: 1   

Located within close proximity to five area beaches, it is easy to envision your dreams becoming a  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Estate Section Acreage
Sold

Shelter Island Estate Section Acreage

Priced at $999,000    Beds: 1   

Located on Shelter Island in Dering Harbor Village, one of the smallest incorporated villages in the  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Restored 1900 Farmhouse with Barn
Sold

Shelter Island Restored 1900 Farmhouse with Barn

Priced at $2,195,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 2374

Nestled within a picturesque rural landscape, enveloped by verdant foliage and time-honored trees,  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Pristine Mid-Century with Meadows
Sold

Shelter Island Pristine Mid-Century with Meadows

Priced at $999,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2    Sq. Feet: 1281

Charming mid-century style home located near a marina, kayak trails, and beach. This pristine ranch  ... Property Details

Shelter Island 1937 Cape Cod Harborfront with Deepwater Dock
Sold

Shelter Island 1937 Cape Cod Harborfront with Deepwater Dock

Priced at $4,450,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2    Sq. Feet: 1622

Behold this enchanting 1937 Cape Cod, that affords a glimpse into the original splendor of Ram  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Pristine Acreage near Resort and Estate Section
Sold

Shelter Island Pristine Acreage near Resort and Estate Section

Priced at $795,000    Beds: 1   

With sloping elevation toward a plateaued building site, this virgin land totaling 1.34 surveyed  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Renovated 1931 Bungalow with Pool
Sold

Shelter Island Renovated 1931 Bungalow with Pool

Priced at $1,695,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 1791

Step through the gate and experience the enchantment of this charming, turn-key Arts and Crafts  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Beach Community
Sold

Shelter Island Beach Community

Priced at $550,000    Beds: 1    Baths: 3    Sq. Feet: 2

This lovely renovated home can be found in "Harbor View," a wonderful Shelter Island beach community  ... Property Details

Montclair Peninsula
Sold

Montclair Peninsula

Priced at $595,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 1752

New listing. Priced for a quick "estate" sale, this 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home is located in a boating  ... Property Details

Immaculate Saltbox with Pool in Private Setting
Sold

Immaculate Saltbox with Pool in Private Setting

Priced at $1,100,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 2 Full, 2 Half    Sq. Feet: 2807

Adjacent to a 20 acre preserve in the Village of Dering Harbor, this New England-style home nestles  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Bungalow Within Close Proximity to Beach and Golf
Sold

Shelter Island Bungalow Within Close Proximity to Beach and Golf

Priced at $439,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2    Sq. Feet: 1759

This 1910 bungalow, located two blocks from Sunset Beach and half block from Shelter Island Golf, is  ... Property Details

Shelter Island 1933 Charming Cape
Sold

Shelter Island 1933 Charming Cape

Priced at $495,000    Beds: 2    Baths: 1    Sq. Feet: 1427

Fringed with delicate and colorful irises and rich with Island history, this delightful cape  ... Property Details

Three bedroom, two bath ranch
Sold

Three bedroom, two bath ranch

Priced at $447,500    Beds: 3    Baths: 2    Sq. Feet: 1442

Three bedroom, two bath ranch on a beautiful treed three quarter acre plus parcel with room for a  ... Property Details

Stylish Island Ranch
Sold

Stylish Island Ranch

Priced at $575,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2    Sq. Feet: 1288

This stylish 3 bedroom 2 bathroom ranch on a half acre property is the perfect size home for minimum  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Best Waterfront Opportunity
Sold

Shelter Island Best Waterfront Opportunity

Priced at $599,000    Beds: 2    Baths: 1    Sq. Feet: 875

A rare opportunity to have a small cottage on the water with dock and easy access to Dering Harbor.  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Mid Century Circular House
Sold

Shelter Island Mid Century Circular House

Priced at $625,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 3.5    Sq. Feet: 1878

This eclectic "round" house is a one of a kind on Shelter Island. Sited on nearly 1.5 acres with  ... Property Details

Adorable Renovated Cottage
Sold

Adorable Renovated Cottage

Priced at $629,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 2    Sq. Feet: 1356

Convenient walk to town and ferry from this cedar shingled 3-4 bedroom, 2 bath home with open design  ... Property Details

Charming Garden Cottage
Sold

Charming Garden Cottage

Priced at $675,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2    Sq. Feet: 1700

Updated 3BR, 2BA home with eat-in country kitchen, enclosed porch, office room with French doors  ... Property Details

Shelter Island Sweet Cape ~ Close Proximity to Sandy Beach
Sold

Shelter Island Sweet Cape ~ Close Proximity to Sandy Beach

Priced at $674,000    Beds: 3    Baths: 2.5    Sq. Feet: 1600

New to the market! Located a short distance to sandy Menhaden Lane beach, this tasteful cape sited  ... Property Details

European Elegance
Sold

European Elegance

Priced at $1,695,000    Beds: 4    Baths: 5    Sq. Feet: 4100

Custom built in 2002 by a European Builder, this 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath, sun-filled and stylish 4100 sf  ... Property Details

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • …
  • 16
  • Next Page »

Contact Me

Lets Chat! Contact me with any questions!
Contact

Stay Connected

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
Penelope Moore

Penelope Moore

Since 1998, Penelope has been the driving force and leader in the Shelter Island real estate market, and is the go-to real estate broker for discerning buyers and sellers. She has experienced record-breaking sales in multiple categories over successive years, and her success has been distinguished not just by benchmark sales, but by volume in all categories.

Meet Penelope

Penelope Moore, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

9 Grand Avenue, PO Box 100
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965-0100

(631) 749-5801
(917) 208-5519 Mobile

Contact Penelope

CRS logo
Saunders Realty logo

© 2026 All Rights Reserved  •  Privacy Policy  •  Accessibility Statement