Sold Listings

Located on 1.4 acres directly across from historic Sylvester Manor and with direct views of the  ... Property Details

Sandy Beach, Deep Water Dock with Lift, Water's Edge Deck + Private Waterfront Gunite Pool. Private  ... Property Details

Located on 1.5+/- acres in desirable Shelter Island Heights, within close proximity to ferry, fine  ... Property Details

Stylishly renovated 1.2 acre island hideaway, located on a serenely pretty pond near Wades Beach,  ... Property Details

Located on the estate originally belonging to novelist Faith Baldwin, this 1981 well-maintained  ... Property Details

This unique property is heaven-sent for the serious boater or the gardener in you. The main house is  ... Property Details

Set on .18 acres and overlooking "the Grove" this charming 1872 Shelter Island Heights clapboard  ... Property Details

This modern barn-style home on nearly 1.25+/- acres is a true sailor's paradise, with 175' of  ... Property Details

This gracious Village estate, built in 1926 and ensconced on a slight hill on 1.92+/- acres with  ... Property Details

Tucked on a hill hidden from view a short distance from the Heights, ferry, Sunset Beach and golf,  ... Property Details

Located within close proximity of glistening sandy beaches on a quiet country lane, and sited on shy  ... Property Details

This chateau located on desirable waterfront peninsula near 40+/- acre nature preserve presents a  ... Property Details

Located in the quiet enclave of one of Shelter Island's estate sections bordering historic farm and  ... Property Details

Located on the southern side of Shelter Island in Menantic Colony, this immaculate and meticulously  ... Property Details

Located approximately two blocks from sandy beach, this well maintained, cedar-shingled ranch style  ... Property Details

This charming farmhouse which was renovated in 2002 is inspired by classic New England bungalow  ... Property Details

Southern facing with prevailing southwest breezes and wonderful elevated views to West Neck Bay,  ... Property Details

Amazing waterfront home with sandy beach, waterside swimming pool and deck. Marvelous views of Bug  ... Property Details

Located in a sought after area of Shelter Island where high end homes are being built, this 1.12  ... Property Details

Be at one with nature, with salt breezes all around, as you take a winding drive to this  ... Property Details