Sold Listings

A rare opportunity to have a small cottage on the water with dock and easy access to Dering Harbor.  ... Property Details

This eclectic "round" house is a one of a kind on Shelter Island. Sited on nearly 1.5 acres with  ... Property Details

Convenient walk to town and ferry from this cedar shingled 3-4 bedroom, 2 bath home with open design  ... Property Details

Updated 3BR, 2BA home with eat-in country kitchen, enclosed porch, office room with French doors  ... Property Details

New to the market! Located a short distance to sandy Menhaden Lane beach, this tasteful cape sited  ... Property Details

Custom built in 2002 by a European Builder, this 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath, sun-filled and stylish 4100 sf  ... Property Details

See virtual tour for more photos! Located within close proximity to beaches, this charming  ... Property Details

Adorable renovated cottage with new cedar roof and siding, full heated basement with 10' ceilings,  ... Property Details

See virtual tour for more photos and video! Allow the sound of waves from the bay a half block away  ... Property Details

With deeded beach rights and in ground pool, this charming new 4BR, 3.5 bath farmhouse features a  ... Property Details

This spacious and sunny traditional, built in 2006, is located steps from Wades Beach and offers  ... Property Details

Located in one of the earliest settlements on Shelter Island, one block from the harbor, this 1904  ... Property Details

See virtual tour for many more photos! Located within close proximity to popular Sunset Beach, golf,  ... Property Details

Enjoy the luxurious lifestyle this magnificent Greek revival has to offer. The finest of classical  ... Property Details

A dream come true! Like a page out of a magazine, this enchanting 1880's Shelter Island farmhouse  ... Property Details

This cheery cedar-shingled farmhouse on 2.7 acres with 105 ft. on tranquil Coecles Harbor offers  ... Property Details

Newly priced! Located at the end of a road, this stylish 3 bedroom cottage is straight out of a  ... Property Details

This Shelter Island beach house has all the necessary ingredients for a fabulous year-round getaway.  ... Property Details

Tasteful traditional in resort area of Shelter Island, within close proximity to Crescent Beach and  ... Property Details

Picture perfect southerly views take center stage at this summery 4 bedroom, 4 bath, all-season  ... Property Details