Sold Listings

Located on Little Ram Island, one of Shelter Island's most desired estate areas, this spacious,  ... Property Details

This gently sloping shy acre, located just outside the Heights, is convenient to Sunset Beach,  ... Property Details

Located near South Ferry and Sag Harbor, this virgin acreage totaling just over one acre has  ... Property Details

This 0.69+/- acre plot is located in Hilo Shores, a boating association along West Neck Bay. Sited  ... Property Details

A rare offering on prestigious Ram Island - Build your own dream house on this virgin .57 acre  ... Property Details

This well proportioned 1.09+/- acre property has a lovely gradual incline from the front, offering  ... Property Details

Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac in the estate section of Shelter Island, in the Village of Dering  ... Property Details

Located within close proximity to marina and Heights, and bordering a large horse farm, this level  ... Property Details

Enjoy spectacular views of West Neck Bay and Creek at this renovated four-bedroom, five-bath home on  ... Property Details

Rental Registration #19L-0128. This newly built Shelter Island waterfront has all of the ingredients  ... Property Details

View the video! This elegant three-story traditional sited on 1.14 +/- acres with 266 +/- ft. of  ... Property Details

Located on desirable Ram Island along a private road facing Mashomack Preserve, this iconic 1934  ... Property Details

Located adjacent to historic Westmoreland Farm on Shelter Island, this bay front traditional is one  ... Property Details

Located between Shelter Island Heights and the Village of Dering Harbor, this vintage traditional,  ... Property Details

Located in estate section within close proximity to wide sandy beach and to West Neck Bay, this  ... Property Details

Located a stone's throw from Shelter Island Heights and beach, this stylish cedar shingled farmhouse  ... Property Details

Located within close proximity to ferry, shops, fine dining, golf and beach, this recently built  ... Property Details

"Pear Tree Acres", located on 2+/- acres with views of Coecles Harbor, was the first A-frame built  ... Property Details

Built in 1949 with many recent updates, this sweet bungalow Shelter Island farmhouse is located  ... Property Details

Hidden behind tall privet hedges with wide stretches of green lawns, this charming and spacious  ... Property Details