As of the week following Memorial Day 2025, the Shelter Island rental market remains flat. Traditionally, the bulk of summer rental activity occurs between Columbus Day and mid-April, with prospective tenants searching and securing leases during that time. This past off-season, however, most inquiries have been for short-term stays or dates that don’t align with typical monthly start and end points.
A growing trend is flexibility in dates, often not disclosed by tenants until multiple landlord inquiries have been made. These shifting requests require diligent follow-up to confirm alternate options, which can slow the process significantly.
Communication remains essential to finalizing leases, yet this season has seen sluggish responses from both tenants and landlords—even after dates and prices have been confirmed. In many cases, messages go unanswered for days, leaving both parties frustrated and delaying agreements.
Short-term rentals of fewer than 14 nights require a separate town permit. Many landlords are reluctant to pursue this additional step or the extra work involved in quick turnovers, pushing more short-term renters to sites like Airbnb and VRBO—often with little success—before reaching out to local real estate agents for help.
Rental permits are a focus. Shelter Island mandates that listings display a valid permit number, but inconsistencies remain across real estate sites, with some listings omitting permit information altogether or using outdated permits. The town now conducts physical inspections to ensure safety compliance, a policy introduced following a tragic fire in Noyac a few years ago at an unpermitted rental.
Meanwhile, the market for exclusive rentals is expanding. While most listings were historically non-exclusive, some agencies now sign exclusives across all price points. The typical commission remains 10%, meaning on a $25,000 rental, agencies and agents each receive a total fee of $1,250 to split. For most rentals, however, the real reward is the client relationship, not the financial return.
Another complication: major real estate websites, like Zillow and OutEast, don’t accurately reflect short-term availability or monthly pricing, adding confusion for tenants searching for stays under 30 days.
As June arrives, there’s optimism that better weather will entice tenants to commit to longer summer rentals. Landlords are balancing patience with flexibility, hoping the warmer months bring renewed interest to the market.
Leave a Reply